COVID-19: Treatment of clusters in Protestant Churches and the Shincheonji Church in South Korea, a comparative study
Article 11 of South Korea’s Constitution forbids any form of discrimination on account of religion and states that “no privileged caste shall be recognized or ever established in any form.” However, a White Paper released by the Centre for Studies on New Religions (CESNUR) and Human Rights without Frontiers (HRWF) on 24 July 2020 titled “COVID-19: Scapegoating Shincheonji in South Korea” (Introvigne et al. 2020a) highlights various instances when this constitutional principle has been violated. One of them is the discriminatory treatment of a new religious movement, the Shincheonji Church (hereafter Shincheonji), in comparison to mainline Protestant Churches.
Shincheonji, which self-identifies as Christian, has been accused of the acceleration and expansion of the COVID-19 pandemic by the media, state and city authorities, politicians and fundamentalist Protestant Churches. This allegation surfaced when a so-called super-spreader, Patient 31, was identified as a member of Shincheonji in Daegu, a city of about 2.5 million inhabitants. CESNUR and HRWF published an initial White Paper in March 2020 titled “Shincheonji and Coronavirus in South Korea: Sorting Fact from Fiction” (Introvigne et al. 2020b) which systematically debunked myths concerning the moral and legal responsibility of that patient and her Church. This paper found that the reaction of the South Korean authorities was disproportionate, which included measures such as: closing all places of worship for Shincheonji, interrogating the 89-year old Shincheonji founder and leader for four hours before he collapsed, arresting several of the movement’s leaders in July 2020, dissolving its legal corporations, confiscating and destroying property, carrying out a nation-wide tax audit of Shincheonji and its local branches, financially crippling the movement through multi-billion civil suits, and, finally, putting in pretrial detention Shincheonji’s founder and leader after an extensive interrogation on the night of 31 July. Surprisingly, one person who has not been subjected to criminal proceedings is Patient 31.
On the other hand, numerous Protestant Churches have disregarded government restrictions related to freedom of worship and assembly. However, they were not treated as harshly as Shincheonji.
This paper will analyze the treatment of Protestant Churches that refused to abide by the government’s health restrictions as compared to Shincheonji.
It is noteworthy that COVID-19 appeared in these churches about two months before the legislative elections in South Korea, which were scheduled for 15 April. This political context played an important role in the government’s dealings with Shincheonji as well as the refusal by a number of Protestant Churches to comply with restrictions regarding freedom of worship and assembly.
First, this paper will provide a short overview of proactive measures taken by several major religious movements. This research demonstrates that Shincheonji was at the forefront of prevention efforts.
A short timeline of proactive and reactive initiatives
25 and 28 January: Shincheonji issued orders forbidding members who had recently arrived from China to South Korea from participating in religious services (Introvigne et al. 2020b).
18 February: Shincheonji leaders ordered all of their centers in Daegu to close. They also recommended that all members avoid private gatherings and meetings, refrain from meeting each other socially, self-quarantine and to be tested for Covid-19 if symptoms appear.
That same day, orders were issued by Shincheonji to close all its churches and mission centers throughout South Korea. Simultaneously, President Moon held a cabinet meeting and reiterated the need to return to normal daily lives (Office of the President 2020).
22 February: Shincheonji services abroad were also suspended.
25 February: The Jogye Order, the largest Buddhist movement in Korea, announced the suspension of its services at its temples for a month (Ilbo 2020).
26 February: All Shincheonji meetings, activities or gatherings in all countries outside of ceased.
26 February: The Catholic Archdiocese of Seoul announced that all 232 of its churches in Seoul, attended by some 1.52 million Christians, would cancel masses from 26 February until 10 March to prevent the spread of the coronavirus. This was the first cancellation of Catholic services there in 189 years. The religious services of the Myeongdong Cathedral were also to be suspended, but the main hall would remain open for visitors from 10am to 7pm (Kwak, Lee & Kim 2020).
After Shincheonji ordered all congregations and centers to stop gatherings and meetings on 18 February, local governments issued separate administrative orders at a provincial level on different dates that imposed restrictions on religious gatherings for a period of two weeks. However, Shincheonji facilities were ordered to shut for an indefinite period and have remained closed to this day. For example, the closure order dated 21 February that the Shincheonji headquarters in Gwacheon received from the local government failed to mention a date for the end of the “Temporary Closure of the Facilities of the Shincheonji Church of Jesus to Prevent the Spread of COVID-19 Epidemic in Daegu into the Community.”
At the end of February, most Korean Churches, but not all, suspended Sunday services and instead held them online. What happened next was predictable.
On 1 and 8 March, the Grace River Church, a small Protestant Church in Seongnam, Gyeonggi Province, held Sunday services despite calls for caution. On 16 March, 46 members of this church tested positive for COVID-19, making it the second largest cluster in the Seoul area (Korea JoongAng Daily 2020). No prosecution was initiated against the leaders of this Protestant community, no penalties were imposed, members were not scapegoated by the media and the church was not closed by authorities.
The case of Pastor Jeon Kwang-hoon, a political opponent to President Moon
On 24 February, a populist pastor of the well-known conservative Sarang Jaeil Church in northern Seoul, Jeon Kwang-hoon, was arrested and jailed for violating city ordinances banning mass rallies. However, his sentencing was not solely due to this breach of the COVID-19 ban on religious gatherings. He was arrested for being involved in a series of pre-election campaigns, which violates the national Public Official Election Act. Every week, he held a rally calling for ‘A Pan-National Center to Fight for President Moon Jae-In's Resignation’ and appealing for support for a particular political party (Kang 2020).
The South Korean authorities were quick to neutralize this political opponent to President Moon and his administration.
Prime Minister Chung Sye-kyun steps in
On 21 March, Prime Minister Chung Sye-kyun issued an administrative order calling for the suspension of mass religious gatherings, entertainment and indoor sports activities for 15 days from 22 March to 5 April – which, according to the prime minister, was a “critical period” to contain the coronavirus. He warned that “stern legal action” would be taken against churches violating the quarantine guidelines including social distancing during small scale services and checking congregants' temperature (Shim 2020).
“[Such meetings] are actions that threaten not only the individuals partaking in them but also the safety of our entire community,” Chung said. “Now is a time of emergency akin to a state of war, so executive orders should not be regarded lightly as a bluff.”
However, while mass gatherings were prohibited, Chung left room for smaller scale religious meetings. Hundreds of Protestant churches across Korea used this opportunity to hold their Sunday services, without always following the official health guidelines. As there was no obligation to declare such meetings and thus no systematic oversight, impunity prevailed.
The case of the Sarang Jaeil Church
In the “absence” of its pastor, the Sarang Jaeil Church held a Sunday service on 22 March to criticize the Moon Jae-in administration. Over 100 municipal officials and 400 policemen were deployed to the premises to monitor the situation. Some members of the church squabbled with the police as they tried to carry hundreds of plastic chairs from a truck into the church.
“The service held today is an undeniable violation of the administrative order that the city government has imposed on the Sarang Jeil Church. [...] We will strictly impose penalties,” a Seoul city official said (Yonhap 2020a).
Seoul Mayor Park Won-soon, a member of President Moon’s Democratic Party, called the church’s actions “intolerable” at a press briefing on 23 March and issued an order banning the church from holding any gatherings or services until April 5. “The case of the Sarang Jaeil Church constitutes an action that seriously threatens the safety of the community and threatens the [antiviral] goals of the government and the people,” Park said. “The extreme measures we have taken with regard to the Sarang Jaeil Church have nothing to do with freedom of religion, and I’m certain religious leaders will understand” (Shim 2020).
South Korea pledged to take legal action against several Protestant churches for violating the government's guidelines to prevent the spread of COVID-19, the prime minister said after this incident. He added that all members violating the order could face a penalty of up to 3 million Korean won (approximately $2,500 or EUR 2140) (Yonhap 2020a).
At the time of writing, the stage of the proceedings against the Sarang Jaeil Church and its pastor was still unknown.
Other Protestant Churches
Other Protestant churches also held their usual weekend services, with some attempting to adhere to the health guidelines.
The Yonsei Central Church in Guro district limited access to registered members and disinfected all members and vehicles entering church premises. Worshippers were asked to write down their names and contact details on a visitors’ list and to keep their distance from one another during the service (Yonhap 2020a).
On 25 March, it was discovered that at least 28 people had been infected with COVID-19 in the Protestant Manmin Central Church in Guro District, Western Seoul. Numerous people that they were in contact with, including relatives and acquaintances, then tested positive. The church had mainly offered online streaming for services since 6 March, but officials believed that an infected person might have spread the disease when several workers and church members convened earlier to discuss the filming of services. The Seoul Metropolitan Government closed and disinfected the church and assigned 40 officials to conduct contact tracing to block further spread (Namgung and Lee 2020).
No prosecution was initiated against the leaders of this community and the church was not closed indefinitely.
Second wave of outbreaks in Protestant churches
After the two-week administrative order for the period from 22 March to 5 April ended, Protestant churches resumed their Sunday services and small gatherings on weekdays. Three months later, an increasing number of new infections had cropped up in Protestant churches in Seoul and its adjacent cities (Yonhap 2020a).
At the end of June, Yonhap News Agency and Dong-A Daily investigated the worsening trend within Protestant congregations.
On 27 June, Yonhap published the following update and statistics (Shin 2020):
Wangsung Church, Gwanak-gu, Seoul: 22 members tested positive as of 27 June
On 27 June, the Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (KCDC) and Seoul City stated that 22 members of a mega-church in Gwanak-gu, Seoul, Wangsung Church, had tested positive for COVID-19.
The first confirmed patient from this church was a 31-year-old female residing in Seowon-dong, who tested positive on 24 June. The following day, seven members were confirmed to have contracted the virus, and six more were confirmed on the 26th.
Out of these first 14 members to test positive, three of them took part in choir practice on 18 June and seven joined the church’s retreat in Daebudo Island, Ansan City on 19-20 June. One attended the church service on 21 June, and the final member was at all the events listed above.
It is estimated that around 1,700 members attended the service on 21 June, so the total number of confirmed patients may have risen since then.
The KCDC is assuming that the virus spread during choir practice or the retreat. It is yet unknown whether the church members wore masks during these events.
The authorities explained that the Wangsung Church followed guidelines for services such as people logging information upon arrival, placing hand sanitizers on site, maintaining distance between seats, etc. However, it is highly likely that churchgoers didn’t continue these measures at small-scale events, and that this led to the virus spreading.
Just a month before, in May, staff members of ‘pioneer churches’ in the metropolitan area visited different churches for revival meetings every day. They sang hymns and said prayers without wearing masks at these meetings, which resulted in over 70% of the participants contracting the virus.
The reason why Church congregations are quick breeding grounds for COVID-19 is that activities such as Bible studies, singing, and sharing meals involve the spread of droplets which carry COVID-19. Also, oftentimes it is the same participants having repeating contact through these gatherings which increases the risk of contracting it.
Jung Eun-kyeong, the Director of the KCDC, said, “Recently, COVID-19 clusters are tied to religious activities such as church retreats, so we ask for special caution on weekends.” She emphasized that: “If offline services are inevitable, minimize the number of congregants, and restrict activities where droplets can be dispersed such as having meals, singing, and especially joining choir activities.”
As of 27 June, Yonhap found that the following churches had this number of members who had tested positive for COVID-19:
- Manmin Central Church in Guro-gu, Seoul: 41 confirmed patients
- Dongan Church in Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul: 28 confirmed patients
- Campus Crusade for Christ in Jongno-gu, Seoul: 7 confirmed patients
- Additionally, infections linked to Protestant churches emerged outside of Seoul. A few examples are:
- Grace River Church in Seongnam, Gyeonggi Province: 67 confirmed patients
- Water of Life Church in Bucheon city, Gyeonggi Province: 50 confirmed patients
- Newly established churches in metropolitan areas, in Gyeonggi Province (which includes 28 cities around Seoul): 25 confirmed patients
- Meetings of pastors in Gunpo and Anyang, Gyeonggi Province: 22 confirmed patients
- Newly established churches in metropolitan areas in Incheon: 57 confirmed patients
- Jesus Malsseum Silcheon Church in Incheon city, Gyeonggi province: 5 confirmed patients
- Two days later, on 29 June, Don-A Daily published complementary and updated statistics (Dong-A Daily News 2020):
- Wangsung Church in Gwanak-gu, Seoul: 27 cases
- Dongan Church in Dongdaemun District, Seoul: 28 cases
- Lord Glory Church in Anyang, Gyeonggi Province: 38 cases
- Joongang Baptist Church in Suwon, Gyeonggi Province: three new cases occurred and public health authorities said 717 people have been identified as close contacts.
- Onchun Church in Busan Metropolitan city, Gyeongnam province: 39 cases
- Metropolitan Area Pioneering Church Meeting in Seoul: 37 cases.
No sanctions were ever enlisted against these churches nor their pastors. They were never asked to provide lists of all their members and attendees of religious services, unlike Shincheonji.
Facing a second wave of infections in Protestant churches, the health authorities hesitated about the measures they should take. They finally opted for a ban on small gatherings and meetings in churches. On 8 July, they announced that Protestant churches would have to suspend their Bible classes, choir practices and lunch services from 10 July. They would also have to use QR-codes on entry logs to keep records of worshippers participating in services. Congregations would also be prohibited from singing and praying loudly.
The United Christian Churches of Korea (UCCK), one of the biggest associations of Protestant Churches in South Korea, immediately reacted with a press release demanding that the government lift the ban.
Another Protestant group, the Communion of Churches in Korea (CCIK), also opposed the government’s decision. “We cannot accept the measures as they labeled the whole Protestant community a hotbed for the virus spread,” the CCIK said (Yonhap 2020b). Ironically, this perceived scapegoating is exactly the treatment that Shincheonji had endured for months and that was actively supported by Protestant churches.
Throughout the pandemic, the authorities have very carefully dealt with the Protestant churches while adopting a completely opposite attitude with Shincheonji. Tolerance and impunity was shown to Protestant churches, but Shincheonji was met with stigmatization, deceptive and destructive rumors, demands of lists of all members and properties, unfounded suspicions, threats, fiscal harassment, prosecutions, spurious charges, and arrests and imprisonment of several leaders including the founder. This disproportionate and discriminatory treatment seems incomprehensible at first sight but is unsurprising once some religious and socio-political dynamics are brought to light.
The first reason for this prosecution is that there has been a war waged for years by fundamentalist Protestant Churches against Shincheonji. With its around 250,000 members, Shincheonji has been a fast-growing religious movement at the expense of the mainstream Protestant Churches. Under the guise of fighting against “heresies”, they have been desperately trying to recover and retain their followers. For almost twenty years, they have organized the kidnapping, confinement and coercive de-conversion of thousands of their members who converted to Shincheonji, a practice that is illegal in South Korea but that has been tolerated by the authorities (Fautré 2020).
The second reason is political. The fundamentalist Protestant Churches are politically conservative, aligning closely with the parties opposed to President Moon. The weight of the Protestant voting block during elections in South Korea is significant. While campaigning for the legislative elections in the spring, fundamentalist Protestant groups instrumentalized the COVID-19 crisis by accusing Shincheonji of deliberately spreading the virus in South Korea. They organized a public petition asking for the ban of Shincheonji and pressed local prosecutors to charge the 89-year-old leader of the Church, Chairman Lee, with homicide by “willful negligence.” During the election campaign, the opposition accused President Moon of serious negligence and failures in his management of the COVID-19 crisis. The reaction of the governmental coalition was to place the blame on Shincheonji, which coincided with the interests of the Protestant Churches.
Now that the parliamentary election is over, the fundamentalist Protestant Churches see a unique opportunity to destroy Shincheonji, which has always been their objective. The COVID-19 pandemic provided an opportunity to sow hostility against Shincheonji, capitalize on other vested interests and get one step closer to the final solution of their problem.
- Dong-A Daily News. 2020. “Is it safe for churches to remain open? Health Authorities’ hesitation could make the situation worse.” Dong-A Daily News, June 29. Accessed July 24, 2020.
- Fautré, Willy. 2020. “Coercive Change of Religion in South Korea.” Human Rights Without Frontiers. Accessed July 28, 2020. https://hrwf.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Coercive-Change-of-Religion-in-South-Korea.pdf.
- Ilbo, JoongAng. 2020. “Time to act responsibly.” Korea JoongAng Daily, February 25. Accessed July 24, 2020. https://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/article/article.aspx?aid=3074250.
- Introvigne, Massimo, Willy Fautré, Rosita Šorytė, Alessandro Amicarelli, and Marco Respinti. 2020a. “COVID-19: Scapegoating Shincheonji in South Korea. A Second White Paper.” Human Rights Without Frontiers, and Center for Studies on New Religions. Accessed July 23, 2020.https://www.cesnur.org/2020/shincheonji-second-white-paper.htm.
- Introvigne, Massimo, Willy Fautré, Rosita Šorytė, Alessandro Amicarelli, and Marco Respinti. 2020b. “Shincheonji and Coronavirus in South Korea: Sorting Fact from Fiction. A White Paper.” Human Rights Without Frontiers, and Center for Studies on New Religions. Accessed July 29, 2020. https://hrwf.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Shincheonji-and-Coronavirus-in-South-Korea.pdf.
- Kang, Yunsook. 2020. “Rev. Jeon Kwang-hoon, Representative of the Christian Council of Korea, Arrested.” Christianity Daily, February 24. Accessed July 25, 2020. http://www.christianitydaily.com/articles/9195/20200224/rev-jeon-kwang-hoon-representative-christian-council-korea-arrested.htm.
- Korea JoongAng Daily. 2020. “It ain’t over.” Korea JoongAng Daily, March 16. Accessed July 29, 2020. http://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/article/article.aspx?aid=3074990.
- Kwak, Jae-Min, Lee Sung-Eun, and Kim Min-Wook. 2020. “Patient numbers exceed 1200, fatalities reach 12.” Korea JoongAng Daily, February 26. Accessed July 28, 2020. https://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/article/article.aspx?aid=3074318.
- Namgung, Min and Lee, Sung-Eun. 2020. “New cluster discovered at church in capital.” Korea JoongAng Daily, 30 March. Accessed July 28, 2020. https://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/article/article.aspx?aid=3075504.
- Office of the President. 2020. “Opening Remarks by President Moon Jae-in at 7th Cabinet Meeting.” Office of the President, February 18. Accessed July 25, 2020. http://english1.president.go.kr/BriefingSpeeches/Speeches/759.
- Shim, Kyu-Seok. 2020. “64 new cases of coronavirus on Monday, some from abroad.” Korea JoongAng Daily, March 23. Accessed July 29, 2020. http://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/article/article.aspx?aid=3075237.
- Shin, Jae-Woo. 2020 “Infection linked to churches emerges once again / 또다시 교회 집단감염…교회밖 소모임서 방역지침 무력화됐나.” Yonhap News Agency, June 27. Accessed July 27, 2020. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20200626163700530.
- Yonhap. 2020a. “Churches push ahead with services despite stricter calls for social distancing.” The Korea Herald, March 29. Accessed July 24, 2020. http://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20200329000245&ACE_SEARCH=1.
- Yonhap. 2020b. “Protestant community protests government’s ban on church gatherings.” The Korea Herald, July 9. Accessed July 27, 2020. http://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20200709000331.